Baton Rouge loses $ 605,000 mosquito management grant to information after years of political, bureaucratic dysfunction
A once promising proposal to use federal grants to fund a tire shredder facility in the East Baton Rouge community is off the table after a series of missteps and misunderstandings across multiple levels of government.
With $ 605,000 donated by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the pilot program was intended to curb the community’s deadly mosquito population that breed in pools of stagnant water that accumulate in abandoned tires.
But after the township missed a state-set deadline to purchase the paper shredder and the Metro Council failed to agree on where it should be, a local contractor was instrumental in the project, who agreed to almost the location to operate free of charge Taxpayers withdrew.
“I felt like the township ended up being very unable to work through some very simple things,” said contractor Diane Baum.
The Louisiana Department of Health announced Friday that it plans to redirect funds for pesticide purchases to mosquito control districts across the state.
The failure of the tire shredder project turned out to be a political lightning rod in the race for the mayor-president. Councilor Matt Watson, a Republican candidate for Mayor-President, and incumbent Mayor-President Sharon Weston Broome, a Democrat, will each be released as competing press releases accuse each other of botching the grant.
Watson, a longtime shredder advocate, said, “We have made it as easy as possible for Sharon Weston Broome’s administration to just follow the process on behalf of the residents here – and even that was too difficult.”
Broome replied that “in political seasons it is typical for candidates to blame the opposition for their failures,” saying Watson “has neither the will nor the ability to make this project a reality”.
The grant is ultimately a drop in the bucket compared to the parish’s annual operating budget of $ 1 billion, but the circumstances that led to its loss offer a glimpse into the bureaucratic and political dysfunction that sometimes plagues the parish government .
Beware of cats
The tire shredder project suffered from too many cooks from the start and communication between agencies was often tense.
“This fellowship had more players than I had ever seen in my experience with the township,” said Kris Goranson, who was responsible for procurement of the shredder as Broome’s purchasing manager.
The CDC made the grant to LDH, which later passed it on to the community’s mosquito control and rodent control, an agency known colloquially as MARC and under the jurisdiction of the Metro Council.
Under a contract with LDH, the township had until June 30th to purchase and install the shredder in order to qualify for a refund. However, following the outbreak of the coronavirus pandemic in March, that deadline was postponed to September 1.
However, the extension was only given orally. The contract was never updated.
The township is ready to purchase a paper shredder before the new deadline, Goranson said, but without a valid contract the transaction cannot legally proceed under the township’s government plan and the deadline has passed.
Even then, it wasn’t clear whether the grant had actually expired, although the confusion was enough for Baum, who soon decided to back off and effectively end the project.
Fed up with political and bureaucratic malfunctions, a local contractor has signed a contract with the East Baton Rouge community to …
On September 25th, the Louisiana Department of Health announced MARC that money was still available for the tire shredder. This news confused MARC’s interim director Randy Vaeth, who told his board of directors, “I have no idea what this stuff means.”
A spokesman for LDH said the agency will be in constant contact with the CDC and the township prior to the deadlines. Vaeth said his contact at LDH was “extremely responsive” but it was clear that the officer was not “at the top of the food chain” and the department was “not exactly proactive”.
It’s not clear why the contract wasn’t updated earlier.
Watson accused Broome’s administration of failing to capture the contract sooner. He said he was inexplicably banned from a purchasing committee tasked with selecting the tire shredder. An indictment which Goranson said inconsistent with his recollections but was nonetheless irrelevant to the missed deadline.
Darryl Gissel, the borough’s chief administrative officer, said the mayor’s office is always tangential to the project and it is up to MARC as the agency that received the grant to ensure the contract is valid.
Vaeth said he was content to take the blame on himself. The interim director was hired on the project last year after his predecessor stepped down on charges of inappropriate spending. At the same time, the council criticized that the tire shredder project had risen to become a $ 1.6 million company.
Vaeth said that as a biologist, the licensing process was unknown.
“If you want to say that someone is responsible for the whole thing, I’ll raise my hand,” said Vaeth. “I couldn’t keep all of these cats.”
Where to find?
Even if the township could have bought the tire shredder, it is not clear where it would have been. For much of the past year this question went unanswered, often engulfing the Metro Council in heated debates over racial and political divisions.
The facility was once earmarked for the construction of 1 acre property rented by MARC near the Baton Rouge subway airport. However, Councilor Chauna Banks, who represents the area, repeatedly argued that the location has overloaded their largely black, low-income district with unwanted industry.
The mayor’s office, seeking a truce, suggested a location near Baker, a location unanimously approved by the Metro Council.
At the time, Councilor Dwight Hudson said, “If we as a panel can’t come to an agreement and come over on this and do this job, then I’d say let’s get the tires over here because that’s about all this is Body would be. ” good for at this point. “
Residents, councilors and other city parish officials grappled at a noisy parish meeting on Tuesday evening that centered on the placeme.
However, a few months later the decision to settle near Baker was reversed after several homeowners in a nearby neighborhood raised concerns that the operation would stunt their community’s growth.
Watson later accused the Broome government of not carefully reviewing the site before offering it as an option to the council, though Gissell said they had obtained approval from local guides before launching it.
After all of the communal lots were found to be exhausted, Baum agreed to buy her own piece of land to house the tire shredder – and rent it to the township for $ 1 – but the proposal never got to Metro for approval Council.
MARC’s Vaeth said retrospectively that he was naive to believe the tire shredder would not face resistance, but at this point he doesn’t think the loss of the grant to Baton Rouge is that bad.
Baum, meanwhile, said she plans to open a privately owned tire shredding facility soon, and although the township will have to pay to drop off tires, she said she will work with MARC to study the effects of tire removal on mosquito populations.
In the end, Baum said, an unpredictable Metro Council and uncoordinated city-borough government made the project too risky for their investors.
“Private companies that invest money need to be sure that the carpet is not pulled out from under them and that they are entering a stable system of local government,” said Baum.
Councilor Matt Watson accuses Mayor-President Sharon Weston Broome’s administration of botched a $ 605,000 federal grant and …
The location of a federally funded tire shredder facility is up for debate again after dozens of Baker residents decided to build a …